The Islamic militants in Pakistan are now targeting remnants of ancient Indus Valley civilisation sites like Mohenjo Daro….writes Dr Sakariya Kareem. Militants in Pakistan have increasingly attacked Sufi shrines, mosques where minority Muslim sects of Shia and Hazaras pray besides churches, Gurdwaras and Hindu temples, killing and maiming thousands. Pre-Islamic Mohenjo Daro, located in the present-day Larkana district in Sindh and Harappa in Sahiwal districts of Punjab have joined the list of sites.
Likely attempt at destruction from Islamic State-affiliated militant groups has emerged as the latest threat to the ancient site of Mohenjo Daro in Pakistan.
This comes in retaliation to the belated, even half-hearted, fight by the Pakistan Army against the militant outfits, most of which it nurtured over long years, but have since gone beyond their control.
“Pakistan’s bloody fight against militancy has raised the spectre of destruction by an Islamist group, much like Islamic State destroyed the ruins in Syria’s Palmyra,” says a report by French news agency, AFP.
The centre of a powerful ancient civilisation, Mohenjo Daro was one of the world’s earliest cities — a Bronze Age metropolis boasting flush toilets and a water and waste system to rival many in modern Pakistan
Pakistan has in its neighbourhood the gory example of the Buddha statues in Bamiyan in Afghanistan. Restored by Indian archaeologists in 1975 under a UNESCO project, they were hit with mortars and destroyed in the year 2000 by the Taliban.
Militants in Pakistan have increasingly attacked Sufi shrines, mosques where minority Muslim sects of Shia and Hazaras pray, churches of the Chtistians, Sikh Gurdwaras and Hindu temples, killing and maiming thousands.
Targets are many, but the non-Muslim ones are especially at risk. And pre-Islamic Mohenjo Daro, located in the present-day Larkana district in Sindh and Harappa in Sahiwal districts of Punjab have joined that list.
The list swells even as the two sites, facing neglect over the years, face erosion from neglect and possibly, eventual destruction. Amidst neglect by authorities, there are no plans at further excavation.
It is a boon in that since what is visible is neglected, why excavate more and make it face vagaries of nature, neglect and now terror? Let us stay buried, experts say.
If nothing is done to protect the ruins — already neglected and worn by time — they will fade into dust and obscurity, the report warns.
The centre of a powerful ancient civilisation, Mohenjo Daro was one of the world’s earliest cities — a Bronze Age metropolis boasting flush toilets and a water and waste system to rival many in modern Pakistan. Some 5,000 years on archaeologists believe the ruins could unlock the secrets of the Indus Valley people, who flourished around 3,000 BC in what is now India and Pakistan before mysteriously disappearing.
But they warn, if nothing is done to protect the ruins — already neglected and worn by time — they will fade to dust and obscurity, never taking their rightful place in history.
“Everybody knows Egypt, nobody knows Mohenjo Daro, this has to be changed,” says Dr Michael Jansen, a German researcher working at the sun-baked site on the banks of the Indus River in Pakistan’s southern Sindh province.
Jansen is at the forefront of a new effort to promote the site internationally while finding ways to protect what is left. In summer, temperatures can soar above 46°C.
“There is enormous thermo-stress,” says Jansen, adding that salt from the underground water table is also damaging the ruins. But it’s more than just the weather and time. Most horrifying, however, is the wanton disregard for Mohenjo Daro — or “mound of the dead” — by ordinary citizens.
In 2014 police stood atop the main stupa as hundreds of people swarmed the site to, ironically, commemorate Pakistan’s cultural heritage — complete with scaffolding, dancing, fireworks, heavy spotlights and lasers.
Sardar Ali Shah, cultural minister in Sindh province, vowed never to let such a thing happen again. “It’s like you are jumping on the bed of a 5,000-year-old ailing patient,” he tells AFP.
Yet today curious visitors still roam the remains with impunity, many leaving rubbish in the once pristine-streets and wells.
Jansen heads Friends of Mohenjo Daro Society. They are working to promote the site internationally, with plans to recruit Pakistanis around the world for conferences, seminars and debates.
Dr Kaleem Lashari, chief consultant to the Pakistani government over Mohenjo Daro, said they will also digitally archive the Indus script — which has never been deciphered — in hopes that making it accessible will increase the site’s profile.
At the site itself, he said, technical reviews are being held to examine the water logging issue and other ways to shore up the ruins, while exploring new, modern technology that allows researchers to ascertain what lies beneath the surface in the portions of the city not yet excavated. But, Lashari says, perhaps the biggest challenge remains Pakistan’s international image, tarnished by extremism, corruption, poverty, and insecurity.
“Foreigners are afraid to visit Pakistan and the site because of the chronic issue of law and order,” he warns. The issues he cites underscore unsettling differences between modern day Pakistan and the civilisation found among the ruins.
At their peak during the Bronze Age, the Indus Valley people are believed to have numbered up to five million, with Mohenjo Daro their largest and most advanced settlement.
Clay and metallic seals, coins, standardised weighing stones, gold and bronze ornaments, toys and whistles — the bric-a-brac of ancient lives have revealed volumes about thriving Indus trade and commerce.
The layout of the city itself suggests an egalitarian people more concerned with cleanliness than hierarchy, says Dr Jonathan Mark Kenoyer of the University of Wisconsin.
“In Mesopotamia, the streets went from the city to the palace … whereas in (Indus) cities all the streets were organised to allow access to the whole city,” he says. Mohenjo Daro had a complex water and waste management system which observers have wryly noted was better than in many parts of Pakistan today.
Only a small portion of the site has been excavated properly, but the most important building appears not to have been a palace or a place of worship, but a massive public bath.
Houses had tiled bathrooms and their own cylindrical brick wells, sometimes raised to the second floor to allow for a flush system. None of this, however, has yet explained why such a powerful, advanced and flourishing civilisation disappeared so abruptly around 1900 BC.
Currently, there is no bid to excavate further among the plans being laid by Lashari and Jansen. “It is actually preserved when it is buried,” explains Harvard University’s Dr Richard Meadow.
Despite their access to new technologies, that puts researchers in a quandary, especially as they try to understand what happened to the Indus people. As Jansen says, the “best way to learn information is to excavate.” But mysteries take time to solve: for now, the researchers say, they will settle for ensuring that Mohenjo Daro endures for a few centuries more.