October 9, 2023
3 mins read

Pak move to evict Afghans runs into protests

While not questioning the government’s right to act, especially against those unregistered, Dawn newspaper asked if it is right in “uprooting hundreds of thousands of human beings who have scraped together a life in Pakistan and sending them back to an uncertain future defined by terror and turmoil seems unnecessarily cold, made all the more so by the short deadline given to them to pack up and leave”

Pakistan’s sudden resolve to evict 1.7 million Afghan nationals from its soil who have not been registered as refugees has run into trouble with Islamist parties and groups protesting and rights bodies expressing concern.
Although the all-powerful army is behind the move during the interregnum it enjoys with an interim, unelected government in office, criticism is conveniently mute on the military and the credibility and efficacy of the government is being questioned.


Maulana Fazlur Rahman, chief of the largest Islamist party, the Jamiat-ul-Ulema (Fazl), has called the move ‘inhuman.’ For Rehman, the present generation of refugees are the descendants of the fighters – Mujahideen – he trained in hundreds of madrassahs along the Pakistan-Afghan border during the 1980s ‘jihad’ against the Soviet-backed government in Kabul. These Afghans, whether or not they have voting rights, are his significant political supporters.  


With Rehman in the lead, the Islamist groups have joined in and those proscribed by the government are working on the ground.

A masked protester sits next to a flag of Pakistan during an anti-Indian protest in Srinagar, November 25, 2016. REUTERS/Danish Ismail


Analysts, both Pakistani and those outside, have said that each phase of instability in Afghanistan since the 1970s has brought in waves of families from the landlocked country. They say that Pakistan facilitated this since it was bankrolled by Saudi Arabia and had the political and military support from the US-led Western world then keen to fight the Russians. In the process, however, Pakistan became the hub of drugs and crime and the influx of armed fighters of various nationalities.

 
In an editorial, Dawn newspaper pointed to the cautions, both legal and on-the-ground practical by various United Nations agencies and NGOs working among the Afghans with last weekend’s massive earthquake in Afghanistan where over 2,000 people were killed and thousands rendered homeless.


It spoke of the “unseemly eagerness” by the caretaker government “eager to forcibly push those who had fled violence, persecution and impoverishment in Afghanistan back into that troubled country.” It pointed to one ministry of the Anwarul Haq Kakar government “even running a countdown on X (formerly Twitter) to remind undocumented migrants about the number of days they have remaining in this country.”


While not questioning the government’s right to act, especially against those unregistered, the newspaper asked if it is right in “uprooting hundreds of thousands of human beings who have scraped together a life in Pakistan and sending them back to an uncertain future defined by terror and turmoil seems unnecessarily cold, made all the more so by the short deadline given to them to pack up and leave.”


Significant criticism has been that the background to the eviction move has been framed in the context of the rise of militancy and terror violence that had an uptick this year. To blame Afghan settlers for this is wrong since various other factors, especially the home-grown militants and Islamists are responsible.

It also pointed to the role of the exploiters, touts and landlords evicting their Afghan tenants causing human misery.

Indicating that the move be put on hold, it pleaded: “At the bare minimum, the ongoing effort to deport all foreigners not holding a valid visa and passport requires international oversight to ensure that those being returned are not deprived of what little they possess in the process.”

“Ideally, the entire exercise needs to be reconsidered, but even if the decision is non-negotiable, the returning Afghans need to be treated with compassion. They are owed that,” the newspaper observed.

Previous Story

Nepal Prepares to Repatriate Citizens In Israel

Next Story

EC sounds poll bugle in five states

Latest from Arab News

Virgin Atlantic Launches Heathrow–Riyadh Route

With Riyadh rapidly evolving into a dynamic hub for commerce, tourism, and cultural exploration, the new route strengthens the city’s position as a gateway to the Kingdom’s diverse offerings King Khalid International

Modi Strengthens Defence, Energy Ties in Saudi

Both sides agreed to hold the next Strategic Partnership Council meeting at a mutually convenient date….reports Asian Lite News India and Saudi Arabia have expanded their bilateral Strategic Partnership Council by adding

Muslim World League Condemns Terror in Pahalgam

Prime Minister Modi commended the firm stand of the Muslim World League against extremism, terrorism and violence….reports Asian Lite News The Muslim World League has condemned the horrific terror attack in Pahalgam,

Pahalgam attack: Modi Cancels Saudi Plans

Sources said that the Prime Minister also skipped the official dinner hosted by Saudi Arabia and has decided to cut short his visit…reports Asian Lite News Prime Minister Narendra Modi will shorten

Modi Begins Saudi Visit

This will be Prime Minister Modi’s first visit to the historic city of Jeddah where the second meeting of the Strategic Partnership Council (SPC) will also take place…reports Asian Lite News Prime
Go toTop