March 29, 2023
2 mins read

Questions linger over unbridled powers of Pak Chief Justice

Experts said that bar councils and associations had long pressed for the CJP’s authority to be organised and regularised…reports Asian Lite News

Although legal experts agree with Justices Syed Mansoor Ali Shah and Jamal Khan Mandokhail’s call for the framing of proper rules governing the chief justice’s discretionary powers, they say that the Supreme Court should determine whether the decision was a “3-2” or “4-3” judgement, reported Dawn.

Salman Akram Raja, an attorney, said on the Samaa TV programme “Nadeem Malik Live,” as quoted by Dawn, that the five-member bench hearing the PTI’s petition contesting the electoral body’s orders to postpone the Punjab Assembly elections would determine whether the “3-2” or “4-3” ruling was applicable to the March 1 order.
He said, “It will be clear in a day or two. This is no big deal.”

Umar Ata Bandial(twitter)

“There is no rule which says a full court will sit [….] we consider the bench to be the Supreme Court. Now, a bench is hearing the matter and it will decide what the previous verdict was. We will have to accept the decision,” argued Raja.

He said “all issues” raised in the dissenting note were important. Raja, however, called the demand for having the apex court’s suo moto jurisdiction as being a precise one. He added, “We should formulate rules immediately. However, we cannot just reject the past by saying that it was a ‘one-man show’ or chief justices made the benches.”

He said that the lack of consensus among the senior court judges was the reason why such guidelines had not yet been developed.

Legal expert Salahuddin Ahmed, on Geo Television show Capital Talk, as cited by Dawn, said that bar councils and associations had long pressed for the CJP’s authority to be organised and regularised.

“You can’t leave it completely to his discretion and as today’s judgement [shows], very harsh language has been used and judicial imperialism has been mentioned.”

Ahmed noted that the need for reforms had previously been brought up frequently and that several judges had expressed dissatisfaction with the so-called selective composition of benches in political or sensitive cases during their retirement addresses.

“When seven to eight or a dozen judges are saying this, then the chief justice is responsible for not allowing the people to get the impression that you are running the institution through certain judges.”

He questioned why the chief justice was delaying the formation of a full bench in order for all judges to sit down together and “speak with a collective authority so matters are actually solved instead of becoming more complicated.”

Echoing Raja’s views, he said that the present five-member panel would have to decide which of the two verdicts was.

He said that the latest turn of events was compromising the SC’s integrity.

He added, “The matter is simple when you include the same three to four judges in important constitutional and political cases, then naturally people will have reservations,” Dawn reported. (ANI)

ALSO READ: Pakistan not to attend 2nd US Summit for Democracy

Previous Story

India to host SCO NSA meet

Next Story

India’s G20 Presidency reaches milestone

Latest from -Top News

Trump tariffs send world markets into panic

US benchmark crude oil shed $2.70 to $64.25 a barrel after major oil producers announced they plan to increase production. Brent crude, the international standard, was down $2.63 at $67.51 a barrel

EU prepares retaliation for Trump’s tariffs

The European Commission is assembling a fresh round of counter-tariffs aimed at US goods, adding to two existing lists of potential targets—one of which includes products that were hit by suspended tariffs

US, EU slam China’s war games near Taiwan

US President Donald Trump underscored the need to maintain peace in the Taiwan Strait, advocating for a diplomatic approach to cross-strait tensions while warning against the use of force The United States

£13.9 billion of R&D fund to boost innovation, jobs

Funding outlined to support transformational R&D in areas like life sciences, green energy, engineering and beyond More UK innovators like those developing treatment-transforming dementia tests or building world-leading testing facilities to power

OPEC+ accelerates oil output hikes

Despite the production boost, the group emphasised that future adjustments remain flexible and could be paused or reversed depending on market conditions. Eight OPEC+ nations have unexpectedly decided to accelerate their oil
Go toTop

Don't Miss

Is TTP forging an alliance with armed rebels in Balochistan?

Baloch rebels have changed their tactics and have upped the

Shehbaz Sharif to lock Imran, allies

The Sharif government believes that PTI ministers of the former