August 13, 2021
2 mins read

Right to shelter doesn’t mean govt housing for unlimited period: SC

The bench said the right of shelter to the displaced person is satisfied when accommodation had been provided in transit accommodation….reports Asian Lite News

The Supreme Court has held that the fundamental right to shelter cannot be construed as a right to government accommodation for retired government employees.

A bench of Justices Hemant Gupta and A.S. Bopanna noted the right to shelter is a fundamental right, that may not be disputed, but such a right of shelter is granted to millions of Indians who do not have shelter.

“A section of society, more so retired government employees, who had earned pension, drawn retirement benefits, cannot be said to be in such condition, where the government should provide government accommodation for an unlimited period,” it ruled.

The bench said the right of shelter to the displaced person is satisfied when accommodation had been provided in transit accommodation. “The direction to allow a retired government servant to retain government accommodation for an indefinite period, to say the least, is a distribution of state largesse without any policy of the state. Such right of shelter does not and cannot extend to provide a government accommodation,” it held.

It was argued that the right to shelter is a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution. Counsel for the respondent cited Delhi High Court judgment, where the Centre was directed to provide alternative accommodation to 24 petitioners, including a former Director General of Border Security Force, and their families subject to payment of a normal license fee.

The top court observed that judges of any forum shall vacate the official residence within a period of one month from the date of superannuation/retirement. However, after recording sufficient reason(s), the time may be extended by another one month, it added.

The bench further observed that compassion could be shown for accommodating the displaced persons for one or two months. “But to allow them to retain the government accommodation already allotted or to allot an alternative accommodation, that too with a nominal licence fee, defeats the very purpose of the government accommodation which is meant for serving officers,” it added.

The bench observed that a section of the migrants cannot be treated as preferential citizens to give them the right to shelter at the cost of millions of other citizens who do not have a roof over their heads. “Such right of shelter does not and cannot extend to provide a government accommodation,” it added.

The top court judgment came on an appeal filed by Centre against an order passed by a division bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which allowed a retired employee of the Intelligence Bureau, to retain his government accommodation at a nominal fee till the prevailing circumstances in his native state, J&K, improved, and he was able to return. The top court set aside the high court judgment but allowed the respondent to vacate the government premises on or before October 31.

ALSO READ: Quad officials discuss cooperation on supply chain, critical technologies

ALSO READ: SC pulls up Centre for failing to give details of cases against MPs, MLAs

Previous Story

Decision on Covaxin emergency authorisation expected by Sept: MEA

Next Story

Mere identification in test parade not substantive basis for conviction: SC

Latest from -Top News

Trinidad Eager to Deepen Ties with India: Envoy

Trinidad and Tobago, home to a large Indian-origin population—many of whom are now in their fifth and sixth generations—offered a unique cultural resonance to the visit….reports Asian Lite News Prime Minister Narendra

Labour peer David Lipsey found dead

In the House of Lords, Lord Lipsey was known for his dedication to social justice and his commitment to improving the lives of others The Labour peer, Lord David Lipsey, has been

UK Space Agency set to clean up space debris

Efforts to clean up space debris mark a pivotal step in the UK’s efforts to protect vital space infrastructure and ensure the long-term safety of the orbital environment The UK Space Agency

UK shuts both its Afghan resettlement schemes

According to the Ministry of Defence, the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy has fulfilled its initial objective of supporting Afghans who worked alongside the UK military The government has announced the closure
Go toTop

Don't Miss

UK to create climate of conciliation with India

The UK side presented a detailed summary of the significant

WH foresees robust future for I2U2 with India

Pierre further said that the I2U2 framework is already deepening