December 7, 2022
3 mins read

India submits reply in Nirav Modi’s extradition appeal

Modi’s appeal on the grounds of a point of law of general public importance is a high threshold that is not met very often…reports Asian Lite News

The Indian authorities have submitted their legal response to the application filed by fugitive diamantaire Nirav Modi seeking permission to appeal against his extradition order in the UK Supreme Court.

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), which appears on behalf of the Indian government in the UK courts, had until Monday to file a response in the High Court in London on the 51-year-old diamond merchant’s plea against being extradited to India to face charges in the estimated USD 2 billion Punjab National Bank (PNB) loan scam case.

The further appeal was filed by his lawyers last month after he lost his initial High Court appeal on mental health grounds, after a two-judge bench ruled that his risk of suicide is not such that it would be either unjust or oppressive to extradite him from Wandsworth Prison in London to Arthur Road Jail in Mumbai to stand trial on fraud and money laundering charges.

“We met the December 5 deadline,” the CPS confirmed.

The High Court in London will now make a decision on whether to grant permission to appeal “on the papers”, without a hearing. This process is likely to take some weeks and is not expected to be completed this year.

“If they refuse to certify a question and leave to appeal then that is the end of the road. If they certify a question but refuse leave, then he applies to the Supreme Court directly for permission,” the CPS has said.

Modi’s appeal on the grounds of a point of law of general public importance is a high threshold that is not met very often.

On November 9, Lord Justice Jeremy Stuart-Smith and Justice Robert Jay who had presided over the appeal at the Royal Courts of Justice in London ruled that they were “far from satisfied that Mr Modi’s mental condition and the risk of suicide are such that it would be either unjust or oppressive to extradite him”.

Their verdict also found every reason to accept that the government of India (GOI) will treat its assurances on Modi’s medical care at Barrack 12 of Arthur Road Jail with “appropriate seriousness”.

Home Office sources have indicated that it is unknown if and when extradition may take place as Modi still has legal challenges open to him.

If his attempt to have his appeal heard in the Supreme Court fails, in principle, Modi can apply to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) to try and block his extradition on the basis that he will not receive a fair trial and that he will be detained in conditions that breach Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, to which the UK is a signatory.

The threshold for an ECHR appeal is also extremely high because he would also have to demonstrate that his arguments on those grounds before the UK courts have been previously rejected.

The dismissal of the High Court appeal last month marked a major win for the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Enforcement Directorate (ED) case against the businessman, who has been in prison since his arrest on an extradition warrant in March 2019.

There are three sets of criminal proceedings against the diamantaire in India – the CBI case of fraud on the PNB which caused losses equivalent to over GBP 700 million, the ED case relating to the alleged laundering of the proceeds of that fraud and a third set of criminal proceedings involving alleged interference with evidence and witnesses in the CBI proceedings.

Then Home Secretary Priti Patel had ordered Modi’s extradition based on Judge Sam Goozee’s Westminster Magistrates’ Court ruling in April 2021 and the case is now undergoing an appeals process on that extradition order.

ALSO READ-MBZ receives written letter from PM Modi

Previous Story

Orion spacecraft on course to return to Earth on Dec 11

Next Story

‘Imran relied heavily on Bajwa for every little thing’

Latest from India News

FINAL JOURNEY

Tens of Thousands paid their respects to veteran communist leader VS Achuthanandan whose funeral was held on Wednesday. VS, as he was popularly known, died on Monday at the age of 101.

Hindu Temple Vandalised in Melbourne

Confirming the incident, Victoria Police mentioned they are investigating “four linked incidents in Boronia,” including the temple and two restaurants….reports Asian Lite News In a deeply disturbing incident of racial violence, a

‘I’ll Give It My All’

Kamboj, a right-handed batter and a right-handed medium pacer, first caught the attention of fans and selectors last season during the Ranji Trophy…reports Asian Lite News Indian pacer Anshul Kamboj showed his

Injury Clouds Hopes

With Ravindra Jadeja coming out to bat, the look on Pant’s face suggested that the injury could turn out to be a big issue for India. India have been handed a fresh

From Exile to Empty Tents

Over a million Afghans have been forcibly deported from Iran this year, overwhelming Kabul’s returnee camps as families plead for aid, shelter, and international action….reports Asian Lite News Seven years after leaving
Go toTop

Don't Miss

India second largest country of birth for naturalised US citizens

In FY 2021 Q1, the top five countries of nationality

Lanka to exhaust $500 m credit line by India this month

There are negotiations going on currently to increase the credit